
Photo of the Day, 4/3




Well, it isn’t quite what I would have picked, but…
We now know who will be on the field with the 2026 Philadelphia Phillies this Thursday. The team does look a lot like the 2025 team that won 96 games, and the NL East by a lot, but lost to the Dodgers in the NLDS. It’s also not the same team. The bullpen is way different than last year’s opening day, and postseason versions. The rotation is substantially different than last year’s opening day. The lineup is mostly the same, but there are significant newcomers. The bench looks very similar to not only last year’s, but years gone by.
The Phillies pick their last few spots based on common themes. They want relievers who strike guys out and don’t walk too many guys, even if they’re in low leverage spots. Their last spots on the bench emphasize defensive versatility. Do I really like this? No, but there is logic to it. A team with a great every day Designated Hitter isn’t going to carry bench bats based on just their bats, unless those guys are in a platoon somewhere. A team with Kyle Schwarber doesn’t have a ton of games at DH to hand out, so there’s no point picking a guy just to hit. Hence, you get this team.
So yes, I would have picked Bryan De La Cruz over both Dylan Moore and Garrett Stubbs, but he would have sat a lot and wouldn’t have done a ton of good in extra innings games. Zach Pop and Tim Mayza weren’t amazing in camp, but Zach McCambley didn’t throw enough strikes to make a bullpen for a contender, even if I think he had more upside. Pop and Mayza are Major League pitchers, and as camp went on they showed some of their past swing-and-miss stuff. That’s kind of it.
So here’s my thoughts on who is on the team…
Catchers (2)- J.T. Realmuto and Rafael Marchan
I don’t think you’ll see much change from the same two guys that were here last year, but I do think Marchan needs to show he can handle a more active role this season. The team had a 2.6 WAR (according to Fangraphs) last season at this position, and the starter is entering his age 35 season. Now Realmuto is showing no signs of his arm slipping up, and the challenge system on balls and strikes should actually help with his alleged decline in pitch framing, so his defense may not slip up much at all this season (it might even improve), but he’s 35 and his bat is giving you a .250/.300/.400/.700 with 12-15 homers if everything goes well at this point. If Marchan can hit somewhere around .230 and give you a .650 OPS with solid defense, he’s at least not a steep drop from Realmuto, and it’s more plausible to give him at least a few more starts (and get J.T. a little more rest). The Phillies really could use developing a catcher that they don’t trade one of these years, but Marchan would solidify his future considerably more if he showed he could be a viable starter for 50 games a year. For this year’s team’s chances of going somewhere though, the expectation and hope has to be that J.T. does not go over a 35 year old cliff. If he’s basically what he was last year, and Marchan marginally improves, this position is stable for this year.
Infielders (6)- Bryce Harper, Bryson Stott, Trea Turner, Alec Bohm, Edmundo Sosa, Dylan Moore
Despite much of the dialogue around this team, this is still a really, really good infield, one of the best in the league. Is Bryce Harper elite? The answer is complex. Most players see the quality of their play decline fairly steeply when they start missing significant time. Harper missed 30 games last year and still popped out 27 homers and an .844 OPS. Assuming he remains that level of player, the question is simply how many games will he play this year, and in the six remaining years on his contract? A 140 plus game Harper at first probably hits 30 plus homers, and maybe more than that if his elbow and back (two recent injury spots) aren’t what bothers him. If he actually lays off of more pitches outside of the strike zone and walks more? Well, we’ll see. Trea Turner isn’t really answering questions about being elite this Spring. He won the NL Batting Title for the second time in his career last year and had one of his better defensive seasons. Yet, like Harper, Fangraphs and others aren’t being super kind with their projected WAR for this season (Harper comes only slightly up to 3.9, while Turner drops from 6.7 to 4.4 in their’s). That feels like a fairly arbitrary and steep decline from last year, but he will turn 33 this year, his fourth year in an 11 year deal. Even so, I expect a bit better year from Harper and Turner than a lot of the projections, and they really aren’t my worry here.
Despite my complaints about the bench, I really don’t have any. Edmundo Sosa is a very useful player, especially when his playing time is managed right. He can play almost anywhere on the field close to league average defensively and give you a low .700’s OPS at the plate as your primary utility man getting starts. I know I kind of dumped on Moore making the team, but he’s basically exactly what a 13th offensive player on the roster is supposed to be- he’ll go play any position the team tells him to, won’t make a fool of himself in the field, and he’ll hit an occasional home run. Edmundo will probably give you about 1 WAR, which is fine, and Moore will be right around zero. If either does more than that, it’s a real treat for the Phillies. Also, we should hope that neither really matters overly much.
How this season is judged, and maybe how fast the team fast forwards to it’s future, really rides on Alec Bohm and Bryson Stott. Part of why the Phillies haven’t won a championship yet with this group is that while these guys are actually good players, they have not become good enough. Alec Bohm is in a walk year, he’ll turn 30 this Summer, and he’s a career .279 hitter with below average to average power. If he had more power, he’d have been extended with his ball-to-bat skills, but he hit 11 home runs last season. He’s likely to be their four hole hitter to start the season. Is he nearly as bad as the people who beat on him on the internet say? Absolutely not. He’s a 2 WAR to 3 WAR player at this point in his career, depending on health, and that’s okay. He’s not really as far worse than Max Muncy at this point as you might imagine, but Muncy’s eight years in LA produced a lot more 30 homer seasons than 10 home run seasons, and that’s why you think he is. As for Stott, the situation is similar, but not the same. Stott has an elite, not adequate glove at a very demanding defensive position, and so the Phillies have been more willing to put up with his growing pains. He’s 28 though now, and coming off of a very productive second half. Even so, the Phillies have not been able to rely on Stott’s bat any more than Bohm’s when they’ve needed to, and he didn’t pass the test when put in the leadoff spot last season. Again, Stott’s glove gets him a lot of room, and his spot in the order being at the bottom means he could end up getting extended if he even takes a mild leap forward offensively this season. As is, he’s been a roughly 3 WAR player that teases you that he has more. If these guys were to realize the potential that was seen in them when they were first round picks, this team *could* win the World Series based on that. That’s not as likely after five years in the league though and as you approach 30. You kind of are what you are, and in their cases, that’s a guy one and two seasons from free agency, looking for a pay day. The other obvious factor here is Aidan Miller, a 21 year old potential future 30/30 player who will probably begin playing in AAA with the IronPigs. He produced an .825 OPS and over 50 steals across AA and AAA last year, and if he is playing like that this Summer, he probably won’t be doing it in the minor leagues anymore. So frankly, the two starting infielders *not* named Harper and Turner probably will be a huge piece in determining this team’s fate.
Outfielders (4)- Adolis Garcia, Justin Crawford, Brandon Marsh, and Otto Kemp
A lot of fans are really down on this group and in my mind, I just can’t quite understand why. Are they elite? Definitely not on paper. You started Nick Castellanos, Johan Rojas, and Max Kepler an awful lot early last season, and Castellanos and Kepler were clogging up this outfield all the way to the end. Castellanos has had points in his career where he was a very good, even All-Star player, but that guy has been gone for at least the last two years in Philadelphia. He was one of the worst defensive outfielders in baseball last season, if not the worst, and it’s mostly because he simply had little to no range anymore. He put up a -.6 WAR last season, meaning he was a liability in almost every way you can imagine a player being so, and that’s not getting into the issues in the locker room, allegedly. Max Kepler was brutally bad, and probably should have been dumped in favor of Crawford last year, but the Phillies decided to prioritize Crawford’s playing time and development and instead brought Bader in via trade and made Kepler share time with Castellanos. Kepler gave you a .6 WAR, and that was with a better finish offensively than his overall numbers, and above average defense. Even so, he’s below an average major league starting player. Both of these players are gone, and thanks to the MLB drug testing program, we won’t spend another half season starting out by trying to see if we can make Rojas into a useful offensive player. The new group may not look all that great to you, and maybe they’re not, but it would be very hard, if not impossible for them to be worse. The three guys who aren’t here put up .4 WAR between them and two of them have now tested positive for PED’s.
The only two fears you can have are that Marsh doesn’t match a very good 2025 overall and that Crawford falls short of the season he had in AAA and isn’t an upgrade on Bader. Both of those things could credibly happen. Even so, Fangraphs pegs Marsh for a steep drop from 2.4 WAR to 1.6, from a .280 batting average to .256, and only a mild upswing in power from 11 to 14. They project Crawford, who hit .334, with an .863 OPS, and 34 XBH’s to produce just a .276 average, .714 OPS, and 33 XBH’s, coming out to a 1.9 WAR. I’d be surprised if both of them don’t exceed those projections easily, even while falling short of their 2025 numbers overall. That leads us to Adolis Garcia, a signing that a lot of fans have whined and complained about all Winter. Yes, Garcia is another one year, $10 million signing, like Kepler. And yes, he might just be that kind of player. His .274 OBP last year is simply unacceptable, especially if he’s *only* hitting 19 homers again. Garcia is a really good defensive player and posted .7 WAR last year largely on that alone. He’s also kind of playing for his career. So for him to be better than he was, we’re talking about beating a .227/.271/.394/.665 slash line, hit at least 20 homers, and continue playing elite defense. If he does that, he’s already better than Kepler was, regardless of what the actual result is. The bar is pretty low here. Fangraphs is projecting him to hit 28 homers and post a .241/.298/.442/.740 season, coming out to 1.5 WAR, and while I would hold my horses a bit on this, it’s plausible. Like I said, I’d take a 1 WAR season here, and I kind of expect we’ll get it. This leaves us with Otto Kemp, who debuted last year and was probably over exposed a little bit. He was a -.2 WAR that posted 8 homers and a .709 OPS. If he gets the bulk of his at-bats this season, no, damn near all of his at-bats against left-handed pitching, I think he can be better than that, and his AAA time suggests that. Fangraphs pegs him for a .3 WAR season, which again, I think he can beat if he’s just used to wear out lefties. I’ll concede the worst case scenario though in my mind- Marsh and Crawford combining to just be 3.5 WAR together, a 1 WAR season from Garcia, and a zero for Kemp. Last year’s outfield, even with Bader having 1/3 of a career year here, only posted about a 3.8 WAR, and I would have this year’s at 4.5 in the doomsday scenario. Obviously there’s room for all four of them to be better than that. They’d almost have to try to be as bad as last year’s crew. And obviously, there’s still the trade deadline.
Designated Hitter (1)- Kyle Schwarber
Kyle Schwarber has been consistently between really good and great in each of his four years as a Phillie. He hasn’t hit less than 38 homers here. He has hit less than 30 homers one time (excluding 2020) in his eight real seasons in the league (he missed basically all of 2016 before the playoffs and came up later in 2015). His walk rate is consistently around 13% or higher, his strikeout rate has stayed steady and even dropped a little in the past two years. His OPS has stayed over .800 in every year other than 2020 since 2018, his second full season. Even his batting average has improved the last two years. What I’m saying to you is that Schwarber is a consistently elite power hitter and you shouldn’t worry much about him this season.
With that said, last season was clearly the best season of his career, and it wouldn’t be normal to start having your uptick at 32, even with the DH coming into his career a little later. Fangraphs has him dropping from 4.9 WAR to 3 WAR, and while that’s a little steep, it’s believable. I tend to think it will be more like 3.5-4, which is still incredible for a one way player. Even so, I’m saying you shouldn’t expect him to top 2025 this year.
The Rotation (5)- Cristopher Sanchez, Jesus Luzardo, Aaron Nola, Taijuan Walker, and Andrew Painter
Elite. Elite. You heard me right. The Phillies won the NL East in a runaway last year basically because of three offensive players, two very nice deadline trades, and the best rotation in the sport. In no other way were they spectacular. For close to four months, Zack Wheeler was the third best pitcher in the sport, then obviously he had a life threatening condition. Cristopher Sanchez was legitimately a top five pitcher in the sport for the season. Jesus Luzardo finished 7th in the Cy Young Vote, had the 3rd highest WAR of any NL starter, and set career highs in innings and strikeouts. Ranger Suarez gave them 26 starts and 157.1 innings of 3.20 baseball. Aaron Nola had the worst year of his career, and it didn’t really even hurt them. Taijuan Walker even produced a 123.1 inning, 4.08 season in 21 starts. Even with Andrew Painter not helping last year, the Phillies starting was simply elite.
To hear some tell it, the Phillies may fall off substantially this year. Wheeler is lucky he survived with his health and you shouldn’t expect him to be back. Suarez is gone. Sanchez and Luzardo had the best seasons of their lives and shouldn’t be expected to repeat them. Nola looked shot. Walker overachieved. Painter had a concerning season in AAA. It is fascinating that like the lineup, a lot of worst case scenarios are being expected. Wheeler is ahead of schedule in his recovery and will make his first real start next Saturday in AAA Lehigh Valley. Sanchez and Luzardo both look healthy and ready to go. Nola and Walker had outstanding Springs. Painter showed good signs of better command this Spring and just had his best start in his last one. All of a sudden you start hearing a few voices predicting a repeat of last Summer.
Pitching is fickle though and the truth is probably somewhere in between, even if it is probable that they are again a top three to five rotation. It will be hard for Sanchez or Luzardo to match 2025. Fangraphs has Sanchez going from a 6.4 WAR season to a 4.8 year, despite another 200 innings, mostly because they think his strikeout rate will fall a little bit and his walk rate will increase a bit. I’m not sure why they think a 29 year old coming off of a breakout season will regress as much as they do, but it’s reasonable to say he may not match a Cy Young runner-up performance. They are not projecting a very different season for Luzardo, putting him back around 180 innings and a slightly lower ERA actually, but projecting a slight drop in his strikeout rate and a drop in WAR from 5.3 to 3.5. Again, that feels steep to me. My guess with both is a very small decline is possible (but not inevitable), but not as far as they are guessing.
How good this group is probably rides heavily on Wheeler and Nola and what they are at this point. In the case of Wheeler, this is kind of hard to project. I mean, the guy could have died from a blood clot. But he didn’t. And by all accounts his rehab is ahead of schedule and he could be pitching in April. That would mean maybe as many as 30 starts and 5.5 months of Wheeler. Last year he missed the last two months of the season and only made 24 starts. Is he going to come back though and be a top three to five pitcher on the planet this season? They are projecting him to drop from a 4 WAR to 3.5 WAR season. That doesn’t seem insane to me, unless he’s 90% or more of who he was healthy last year. He really may be though, and the track record on guys coming back from this is mixed, but improving in recent years. If he is basically himself by May, I think he’ll probably end up giving the Phillies considerably more value than 2025. We’re just going to have to see how he performs live though. As for Nola, I think at least some bounce back is likely. From 2018 through 2024, with the exception of the shortened 2020 season, Nola surpassed 180 innings every season and had an ERA below four in all but two seasons. Last season he made just 17 starts, threw just 94.1 innings, and had a 6.01 ERA. He’s either totally shot and this contract is a literal albatross on the team, or last year really was caused at least in part by an ankle/leg injury and better health alone will make him better. His Spring and World Baseball Classic suggest we’re going to get a much more normal Nola. Even if Nola is a bit more hittable now than a few years back, there’s no reason he can’t be a low four’s ERA, 30 start, 175 inning fourth starter. If Wheeler is a healthy two and Nola is a dependable four, and Sanchez and Luzardo are close to last year, this is a really good rotation. Not as good as last year, but really good. If Wheeler is Wheeler and Nola gives you a more career normal Nola, this is an elite rotation that will be as good as anyone in baseball. Yes, really.
Which leads me to the subject of Taijuan Walker and Andrew Painter, both of whom are going to be talked about a lot more this week than they really need to be. If the four guys I talked about above basically hit their benchmarks, these two are only being asked to be a league average fifth starter or swing man in an elite rotation. If those four are as good as they can be, all these two are really being asked to do is be a footnote. Now, we know the situation with both of them. Walker was maybe the worst pitcher on the planet in 2024 and his four year deal looked like a complete disaster, and then last year he came back and gave them a very professional, well above league average fifth starter kind of season. I don’t think we should expect better than that, but much like with Adolis Garcia, this guy is literally pitching for his future this year. A solid season from Walker will get him at least another season of Major League money. A dud might end his time in the league. With Painter, obviously the ceiling and hopes are quite a bit higher. He was the top young right handed starter in some prospect rankings at the time of his 2023 elbow injury. He sat for two years, then he had struggles last season in his first season back, facing AAA hitters for the first time. His velocity mostly returned, but his command didn’t, and some folks have thought out loud about both his arm angle and the “shape” of his fastball. The truth of the matter is that Painter is still a work in progress, and fans dreaming of him coming in and being an ace next week are living in a fantasy. The point of last season for him was pitching near a complete season and staying healthy, and he did that. The Phillies are now working on fixing his flaws. By all accounts, they have his arm slot back where it was pre-Tommy John, which is an incredibly good sign, and probably at least in part explained his good Spring. Now they need to get back some combination of his triple digit velocity, ride on his fastball, and the natural cut he had on it. Yes, his last start was his best so far, but it’s probably unfair to think they got everything fixed in four starts. A lot of people aren’t going to like this, but the odds are strong that Painter will be the guy sent to AAA in a couple of weeks when Wheeler comes off the IL, regardless of whether or not he out pitches Walker. There is still work to be done on him, and it’s much better to do that work in AAA than the majors. With that said, let’s compare the situation the Phillies are in with say, everyone else. While other teams are asking their top pitching prospects to step in and be say, a number two (Nolan McLean in New York), the Phillies really only need Painter to be a reliable five this season, as they work on him. The pressure, if our damned talk radio crowd would quiet down, should be very low. If they can bring back the movement and “life” on Painter’s fastball, yes, he can absolutely slot very high in this rotation. That could happen at any point, and it has for plenty of pitchers who had Tommy John. It also may not, and well, he may have to learn to pitch crafty enough to just survive as a back end starter. I’m not saying that will happen, just that it could. The point is I’d be thrilled if we get 20 starts that grade out to league average, and the starts late in the Summer start looking like a top ten prospect in the game type again. Hell, I’d be fine if he pitches 25 plus starts and is simply better than the league average fifth starter. This kid is 23 and here on a league minimum deal. With Sanchez and Luzardo locked up for a while, Painter doesn’t need to be a number one or two starter this Summer for this team to win, and can get his stuff back to where it was over the course of this season and just show us it’s still there.
The Bullpen (8)- Jhoan Duran, Brad Keller, Jose Alvarado, Tanner Banks, Jonathan Bowlan, Zach Pop, Kyle Backhus, and Tim Mayza
Be careful here- this group actually looks elite. Jordan Romano and Joe Ross are gone. David Robertson and Matt Strahm have been replaced by Keller and Alvarado. You get a full season of Duran. While the ending of the season was unfortunate and he will start the season on the IL with a hamstring issue, Orion Kerkering showed signs of his stuff starting to play up in the postseason last year. The Phillies probably have five or six arms that grade out somewhere between elite and durable and steady. Then there are three basic wild cards out there behind them. Pop and Mayza have had past success in the majors, and have also bombed in the past. Both showed signs they might be able to reclaim some of their higher strikeout rates at times this Spring, and really you’re just hoping that one of them, or both, does it. Backhus is a long, weird left-hander, and he has shown some ability to be really tough on lefties. If he does that, he’s fine as the third lefty in the pen. Any one of these three could blow up and be a problem, and the odds are that one will. Even more so, the odds are strong that one of those six “steady” guys I talked about will either face an injury or struggle at some point this season. This bullpen looks elite. As long as Duran, Keller, and Alvarado are healthy and performing at their expected levels, it is elite. That’s even more true if Kerkering, Banks, or Bowlan show something. But history tells us that won’t probably all happen at once. History also tells us that the nine guys I’m mentioning won’t be anywhere near all the guys who end up playing a role here. Max Lazar pitched a lot for last year’s team. Lou Trivino was actually fairly impressive to me last year at times in both AAA and the majors for us. Seth Johnson’s fastball really had me intrigued this Spring, as he seems to have gained a little something on it. There are others, such as Griff McGarry, Chase Shugart, Yoniel Curet, Bryse Wilson, and Nolan Hoffman who could surprise you at some point.
Still, I do expect this group to be much stronger than others. Fangraphs likes Duran (2.1 WAR projected), likes Jose Alvarado (1.2 WAR), and for some reason hates Keller (.2 WAR). They are higher on Banks (.5 WAR) and Kerkering (.4 WAR) and less excited about Bowlan (.1 WAR). They put Mayza in the same spot as Bowlan, and expect a net zero from Pop and Backhus. I’m not going to quibble with them on Mayza, Pop, and Backhus, all of whom will be pitching in low leverage spots at least at the start. Duran and Alvarado being that good would loom large, and if they’re healthy they should be. I’m hoping for a bit of a breakout from Kerkering, but it’s hard to argue with the numbers for him and Banks they give either, based on usage. I’m really only in real disagreement on Keller and Bowlan. Keller obviously had a really good year with the Cubs last year, but they are projecting quite a drop-off this season. Bowlan could be a bit hard to project, as he was a late bloomer, making his debut at age 28, and also potentially swinging between mid-to-low level leverage spots and long relief duty. Even so, he did a good job avoiding hard contact last season, which is in and of itself a bit of a skill. I definitely both of them will be a bit better than the projections here.
I tend to think that bullpens with fairly defined roles do pretty well. This doesn’t mean only one guy closes, but it means someone is the primary guy there and then there are other very good relievers who tend to get the eighth inning, and you slide back from there based on situations and the score. If Keller excels like I think from having a set 7th or 8th inning role, and Alvarado pitches to his potential as the main lefty counterpart to him, this team isn’t going to blow many leads. That’s really asking for three guys to have very good to elite seasons though. It happened for the team in 2008, but it’s a lot more rare than normal. Still, look for this to be one of the top units in baseball.
Who else might help?
Ok, I could say Aidan Miller here, and I believe that, but that’s too easy. At some point this summer the top prospect the club has had in years will be hot and the fans will want him called up, and he probably will be. There’s a really strong shot that Miller, Crawford, and Painter all contribute positively this season to a team that contends for a title, and that’s a huge credit to the player development folks, as for that matter would a positive contribution from Otto Kemp or Marchan. They developed these guys, and to the clubs credit they weren’t willing to part with them. There’s a good chance three rookie top prospects end up rewarding them to varying levels this year.
Now that that’s done, I named you a bunch of bullpen arms. If you put a gun to my head and said narrow that list, I’d say Seth Johnson and Lou Trivino are my candidates to really surprise, and Bryse Wilson is a guy I could see giving them durable (not great) innings later. You want a real dark horse? It’s McGarry. I think the Nationals messed up not just holding onto him and working on him. He showed some signs of late blooming in 2025, and they’re going nowhere anyway. Look, maybe this guy never figures out how to throw enough strikes, and maybe he does. Time will tell. The other guy with enough talent to break out is Curet, but he looked like a serious work in progress this Spring.
Bryan De La Cruz was the last guy off the team and maybe that means he gets a chance. History tells us that can cut either way. Gabriel Rincones had a tough Spring with injuries, but I wouldn’t be stunned if he hit his way back into the picture later this Summer in Allentown, the power is there. If I had to give you two kind of odd ball names to play a role at some point, I’d say Bryan Rincon (probably Reading’s opening day shortstop) and Felix Reyes. Both guys turned some heads in camp. Rincon does have Miller in his way and Reyes kind of lacks a position if he can’t play corner outfield, but both showed some game. Reyes hits the ball hard, and that does tend to play on any team.
Expectations?
As I said at the top, this team went 96-66 and ran away with the division last year. I really don’t buy that they got considerably worse. The division could be better though. Miami played as well as anyone after June 1st last year. I don’t buy that the Mets got much better this off-season, but they didn’t get worse either, they’re adding a few premium prospects as the season goes, and they badly underachieved last year anyway. Atlanta’s camp was dreadful, sure. They will get a full season of Ronald Acuna Jr., and he could be the best player in any given season. Only Washington stinks really. It’s a tough division.
The question is basically did anyone make up at least 13 games? Sure, if you take the view that every Phillies star and top end pitcher has a worse 2026 than 2025, and literally everyone is better in New York or Atlanta, which is basically the view of some folks. I don’t buy that. Fangraphs projects at least .5 WAR improvement at five of nine spots in the Mets lineup this season. They project six starters to have over 1 WAR, which would actually be pretty impressive. They consider their bullpen to really be their weakest link, which again, is probably true. They give the very injured Braves rotation a very similar six guys over 1 WAR projected, which would again impress me, behind a top two who actually should be better if they can stay on the mound healthy. They are projecting healthy bounce back seasons for all of Austin Riley, Michael Harris II, Matt Olson, and Ozzie Albies. I’d be pretty impressed by that. Even so, do I think both of those teams are better? Yes. I just don’t think they’re so much better, the Phillies so much worse, or a combination of the two that we shouldn’t win this division.
Ultimately, I think the Phillies pitching, both starting and relieving, wear out the competition. I think they get a very good Bryce Harper bounce back season, Turner and Schwarber don’t really regress enough to matter, Crawford has a very solid, dynamic rookie year, Garcia bounces back a bit, Marsh is solid, and either Bohm or Stott step up. I think Wheeler returns to ace status, Nola bounces back very solidly, Sanchez and Luzardo are approximate to last season, and the rotation is fine. The bullpen is one of the best in the league. There will be injuries obviously, and I’m not thinking there will be many career years in the lineup, but no one can pitch down to four or five with the Phillies in this division. I don’t think they win 96 again right now, but that’s from improvement in the division. The only team I think for sure wins more games in the National League is the Dodgers (more on them the next few days) and possibly the Cubs. The Phillies should still be a 90 plus win team.

You know how sometimes a lot of stuff happens in a week, but really nothing stands out so you really don’t remember anything? Good times. It’s almost Spring. It’s St. Patrick’s Day tomorrow. No matter how bad life is, it’s good right now. Or it could at least be worse. It could still be early February and there could be snow on the ground. Lots of snow, frozen solid because it’s too cold to melt.
So March Madness is here. Locally, Lehigh University is in the big dance, as are two Philly schools, Villanova and Penn, while St. Joe’s is in the NIT. It seems like most of New York City is in, with St. John’s, LIU, and Hofstra in. I haven’t filled out my brackets yet (that’s tomorrow morning), but I think I’m split between Florida and Arizona at the moment, but also considering Duke. Here in Easton, PA, we celebrate March Matness religiously, with this week’s NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships almost being a religious holiday. I’m taking Penn State to win by a million. In the World Baseball Classic this week the United States and Venezuela have advanced to play a championship game tomorrow night filled with geopolitical irony this year. Phillies Cristopher Sanchez, Aaron Nola, and prospect Dante Nori have all stood out for their teams in this tournament, while Phillies Americans Brad Keller, Kyle Schwarber, and Bryce Harper will play in tomorrow’s final. I’m enjoying it. This past weekend was the New Jersey State High School Wrestling Championships, and while the wrestling was good, two tweets stood out- this one about the best Italian names in each weight class and this photo of an amazing scene at the end of a semi-final match on the IBEW Local 102 mat. Peak stuff. Also if you ever thought of giving up on something, 33 year old Izzy Balsiger became an All-American 13 years after previously achieving the honor at the NCAA Division III Wrestling tournament.
In more serious matters, the United States suffered casualties in a war that it won a week or two ago in Iran. The U.S. Embassy in Iraq was hit by a drone. The President is pressuring NATO and China to reopen the Straight of Hormuz. Gas prices are up. Israel is talking to Lebanon as it increases it’s ground campaign in Lebanon against Hezbollah. White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles has breast cancer and I wish her a speedy recovery. FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has threatened to revoke licenses for television networks that don’t cover the Iran War the way he likes. Congress doesn’t seem super pleased, but they can’t get themselves out of a paper bag. A federal judge has blocked parts of RFK Jr.’s vaccine guidelines. The USDA is making indentured servitude great again, deciding to increase temporary visas for immigrant migrant farmworkers and lower their pay. There are major primary elections tomorrow in Illinois and apparently Altoona, if you believe that. New York City is lowering speed limits to 15mph in school zones. I’m fine with that.
Last night was the Oscar’s. I watched Conan’s opening monologue and thought it was pretty funny, but Conan O’Brien is funny. “One Battle After Another” won best picture. Jessie Buckley won best actress for her role in “Hamnet.” Michael B. Jordan won best actor for his role in “Sinners,” officially making him the second most famous Michael Jordan. “Sinners” won four Oscars as a movie, while “One Battle After Another” won six. Nicole Kidman showed up Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez on the Red Carpet. And in my favorite win, “Mr. Nobody Against Putin” won best documentary feature, a big fuck you to Vlad. I still couldn’t sit there and watch the whole show though, ADHD gets in the way.
Well it’s just about St. Patrick’s Day. Go drink a green beer or some Guinness, throw on your Birds jersey for the day, and blast the Dropkick Murphy’s. Oh, and eat all of the corned beef and cabbage that I don’t get to first.

I feel the need to keep reminding people that the Phillies were actually a 96 win team last year that won their division by a lot. If they’re “running it back,” which they really aren’t, that’s not a bad thing. The Mets maybe improved a bit on paper from last season, but it’s only a bit given the key players they let walk out the door to begin with. The Braves could get bounce back years from some of their best players, but so far in camp they’re losing players to injuries and suspensions. No, the Phillies didn’t sign a ton of new free agents, but given the young talent arriving and the few players they did bring in, I think you have to be trying to find fault with them to not pick them as at least a prohibitive favorite in this division.
Now, with all of that said, you don’t win the division in March. You pick a team in March. The question is, how does this team compare to the 2025 one. That may depend on if we’re talking about the Opening Day team or the playoff team, but the question remains. I’m going to walk through that a bit here.
The Line-Up
SS- Trea Turner
DH- Kyle Schwarber
1B- Bryce Harper
3B- Alec Bohm
LF- Brandon Marsh
RF- Adolis Garcia
C- J.T. Realmuto
2B- Bryson Stott
CF- Justin Crawford
Ok, so absolutely no shocks at all here. My guess is that on days where Otto Kemp is in left instead of Marsh, Garcia and Realmuto will move up and he’ll slot seventh. I’m expecting some regression from Schwarber (I’d be shocked if he hit 56 homers again), but nothing major- he still hits well over 40. I expect a similar season from Turner to last season, at least offensively, but his defense will probably regress. I’m expecting a big season from Bryce Harper, and he’s not off to a break neck pace so far. From there I expect pretty much career norms from four through eight. None are truly bad players, they probably all end up in the range of 2 WAR or better, but none are competing for All-Star nods or MVP’s. Then there’s Justin Crawford. I’m going to keep saying how much I like him, and I think others will eventually join. No, I don’t think he’ll ever hit 30 homers. I do think he’ll continue to grow into a double digit homer guy, and I think you’ll all see that he sprays a lot of extra base hits in the form of doubles and triples. If he’s hitting .300 and swiping 30 plus bags, I think he’s a real asset.
Rotation
LHP Cristopher Sanchez
LHP Jesus Luzardo
RHP Aaron Nola
RHP Taijuan Walker
RHP Andrew Painter
The backbone of this team remains pitching. Sanchez looked rusty in his first WBC start, but looks healthy. Luzardo got paid, and that’s good for everyone. I don’t see Sanchez regressing at all this season. Luzardo did have the best year of his career last year, which makes you think he could, but he also had a half dozen starts that prevented him from contending for the Cy Young, and he could improve on that. The success of this staff is really what happens after those two though. Nola has looked outstanding so far, which has me quite excited. Walker just threw very well for Mexico in the WBC, but I think it’s fair for us all to assume he’s a fifth starter type. Painter has had really, really good results so far. His delivery looks like it did pre-Tommy John, which is really good. He has not missed many bats so far this Spring though, and that is my one pause for concern. As long as one of these three is pretty good and another is a league average five, the staff should be fine though. Zack Wheeler is back throwing bullpens and on target to be pitching by May, meaning he may throw a full month more than last season. Obviously we need to see how he’s doing at that point, but if he’s 85% of the Wheeler we had, the rotation is very, very strong again.
The Bench
C Rafael Marchan
INF Edmundo Sosa
INF/OF Otto Kemp
INF/OF Dylan Moore
I think that Sosa and Kemp are locks to make this team. I think Sosa will continue to be who he has been since he got here in 2022, which is a very good utility player. Kemp is going to get his chance to answer the question of “what he is,” as I think we’ll see him face lefties in left field and accumulate several hundred MLB plate appearances this year. I have Marchan beating out Stubbs for one basic reason- Stubbs can’t hit at all. Neither is going to be an offensive juggernaut, but if you really want 40 or 50 starts from the back-up catcher this year, there’s no responsible way you go with Stubbs. The last spot is a tough one. Topper has said he wants versatility, so I’m taking Moore over Bryan de la Cruz. If I were the GM, I would go the other way. The last guy shouldn’t really get many starts anyway, so I’d rather take the guy I’d be happier with getting plate appearances as a pinch hitter. He also could take some starts in left, though I don’t think the Phillies really want that.
Bullpen
Closer Jhoan Duran
Top Righty Set-Up Man Brad Keller
Top Lefty Set-Up Man Jose Alvarado
Righty Set-Up Man Orion Kerkering
Righty Reliever Jonathan Bowlan
Lefty Reliever Tanner Banks
Lefty Reliever Zach McCambley
Righty Reliever Zach Pop
This seems to be a battle between McCambley, Pop, and Kyle Backhus, with Max Lazar and Seth Johnson on the edges with Lou Trivino and Tim Mayza. I’m taking McCambley and Pop because they have to make the team, or be gone. In the end, they’re going to be throwing mop up innings anyway. The front six in this bullpen are going to be very good. Remember last year, with Romano, Alvarado, and Strahm opening the season as your top three arms? Keep your eye on Bowlan, who appears to be a late bloomer. Last year as a rookie, he was one of the top rookies in opponent batting average. He can give you length and he’s good at limiting solid contact. I’m expecting good things.
Next time out I’ll try and predict the IronPigs as well. I’m not sure how or why people are looking at this roster and predicting a huge drop off from last year’s 96 wins? The Braves are a busted mess and the Mets bullpen will kill them, assuming they don’t miss Pete Alonso too much first. This team basically looks like they’re as better as Crawford and Painter make them, and I think that was always the plan. The Phillies have refused to move these prospects for several years, waiting for this point. I think they’ll be pleasantly rewarded for that.

I really don’t care that Bryce Harper found Dave Dombrowski questioning if he was still elite to be “wild” or not. That’s not a knock on Harper or Dombrowski, both of whom will probably end up enshrined in Cooperstown. It’s just a nothing story. Harper has not uttered the word trade, nor has his agent Scott Boras, and Dombrowski was quick to note he was not ever considering trading Harper. Sure, Harper was asked about the comments again when he arrived at Spring Training, and he did answer honestly, including that he didn’t have an elite season in 2025, according to himself. This is nonsense and should be treated as such. There are much more important things to be covering in this camp.
The Phillies won 96 games last year. Their bullpen is miles better than it was last year to start the season, or for that matter, where it was to end the season. Kepler and Castellanos are gone from the outfield, and while Adolis Garcia may not excite you, he’s a better overall player than them. Of course there is Justin Crawford too, possibly the best player in AAA last season that I saw, who posted an .863 OPS, a year after an .805 OPS. These are better numbers by a now 22 year old than anything we’ve brought up in years. In fact he was better in AAA than top tier Mets prospect Carson Benge, who their fans are rightly excited about sticking into their outfield this year, and is a full year younger. The outfield should be measurably better this year. Turner won the batting title and Schwarber the home run title in the NL last year, so we have no reason to think they’re falling off. And well, Harper should have no problem matching or exceeding last year. The only part of the team that took a step backward on paper is the rotation, because losing Ranger Suarez hurts. If Zack Wheeler is actually back by May and pitching like himself, if Aaron Nola is even a 4.50 ERA type of pitcher, and if Andrew Painter even shows you flashes of his talent this year, they will fill in that hole just fine. This team has things to be concerned about. They absolutely should be a playoff team though. And well, I’m not accounting for Aiden Miller potentially arriving at some point either. He has 30/30 annual talent if he can put it together. The doom and gloom the media have built around this team is nauseating. This is an objectively very good team.
We just went through a season of largely manufactured drama and nonsense around the Eagles, and now we’re starting baseball off on the same foot. The Eagles have been done for a month, no one believes in the Sixers or Flyers, and there aren’t baseball games until Friday, so we get nonsense slop. Castellanos is mostly gone because he was mediocre two years ago (at best) and downright awful in 2025. Matt Strahm is gone because of a couple of playoff meltdowns the last two years, signs of decline, a fairly high salary that outpaced the role he would have had here, and because the Phillies felt they upgraded on him over the past few months. Harper, while still a really good player, was not elite last year. There is no further story, there is nothing to read into it, there’s no smoke, let alone fire. All of the drama coverage is nonsense.
Obviously things will play out on the field. There are real stories to cover. Crawford, Painter, and Miller are to varying degrees competing to carve out roles as rookies on this team. Wheeler and Nola’s bounce backs this season, or lack thereof, will almost certainly determine if this team is as good as last year. Who gets at-bats against lefties instead of Marsh in left field is an actual competition. Stott and Bohm are kind of playing for their futures here. There are lots of things to actually pay attention to in this Phillies camp. None of it is the nonsense we are getting from the press. This is far from “running it back” from last year, and the press is trying to cover this team as if it’s stale and declining with no actual signs of that being true. I’d love to see actual coverage of the baseball team. I’m not holding my breathe that we’ll get it.

When the confetti stops falling on Sunday night sports fans everywhere will turn their attention to Florida and Arizona (as well as the ongoing NBA and NHL seasons and Daytona), and the beginning of the long baseball season ahead. The “hot stove” offseason will have basically run it’s course, and now we’ll have to see how teams actually do on the field. Rarely is there a direct correlation between who wins the offseason and who wins the season, though it was fun. In truth, only a small few free agents have the ability to take a mediocre team and make them good on their own, or a good team and make them great. So the real question is, what has actually changed?
If you read the chronically online portion of the Phillies fan base’s posts, you would think the Phillies were an 83 win team that missed the playoffs last year. They certainly were not that. They were a 96 win team that was basically *three or four plays* from beating the best team in baseball in a playoff series last year. Sure, they lost Ranger Suarez, and that will hurt, but besides that, they have not lost any major difference maker from that team who they did not upgrade on in the off-season. The Phillies clearly went into the off-season with a couple of goals, and did most of them. They kept as much of their core together as they could, re-signing Kyle Schwarber and J.T. Realmuto. They wanted to upgrade their bullpen, something they believe they have done by adding Brad Keller and having Jhoan Duran and Jose Alvarado for the full 2026 season, as well as hoping for sleeper big seasons from Orion Kerkering (who despite the throwing error in game four of the NLDS, seemed to be throwing the ball better than anyone in that bullpen in the playoffs) and Rule 5 pick Zach McCambley. They also wanted to get Justin Crawford and Andrew Painter clear paths to help this Phillies team this season, something both will have a shot to do as the season goes on, as might Aidan Miller. They checked off all of those boxes. As for external upgrades, something that some fans are screaming about, the Phillies only seriously pursued one, a 27 year old right-handed bat who they offered the top market value for, before a team came in and offered 150% of their deal in average annual value. That gap is simply not something you match. On the whole though, the Phillies very clearly did the three things they felt were necessary to stay as a 90 plus win, playoff team.
I suppose it is too strong to say people screaming that this team is regressing are wrong, but there isn’t a lot of evidence for what they’re saying. Unless you think the aggregate output of Trea Turner, Bryce Harper, and Kyle Schwarber is going to fall off of a cliff, the lineup isn’t going to be a lot worse, and that’s even more true if you believe in Crawford as much as most of us who watched a lot of him in his time in Reading and Allentown do. Suarez hurts, there is no doubt about that, but Painter has been a super prospect for quite a few years now, and is only really being asked to be a fourth or fifth starter to start the season, not to mention the track record is decent for pitchers having big bounce back seasons in their second season back from Tommy John. You’re going to get slightly more Zack Wheeler than last season if he actually comes back in May and is healthy, so unless you think he’ll never be the same, the pitching staff could possibly even improve- and I haven’t even factored in that almost anything Aaron Nola does would be better than what he did in 2025, and possibly by a significant margin. Throw in a very, very good bullpen on paper and I don’t see why people are so down on this team. There’s no real reason to be.
There are two factors that can change their result from a third straight division title and possible postseason contender to a disappointment. The Mets did not improve as much as some people are acting (they lost their one big time power bat and an elite closer), but the Mets probably come about even on talent with last year’s group, and they frankly should have been much better then, as should have the Braves- a roster that has wildly disappointed two straight years and should be elite if they are healthy and click. That may or may not all happen though, and even if both of those teams are very good this year, the odds that there are four NL teams better than the Phillies for the four spots they could possible win (you can’t win the other two divisions) are slim. The thing that could bring down the Phillies is not something you can ever predict exactly- health. Major injuries, particularly to the big difference makers on this roster, could bring them down. That can happen to any team in the league though, the Dodgers included. Nothing in Schwarber, Turner, Sanchez, Luzardo, Duran, Alvarado, Keller, or Kerkering’s seasons last year suggest that they are at health risk or in some kind of decline right now. I’m slightly worried about Wheeler because his injury was serious, but all signs are that he’s progressing well. I’m slightly worried about Harper because he’s been on the IL every season since his NL MVP season in 2021, but he’s also still very productive when playing and frankly we just need him to be that in October. My big worries, if I have any, are really J.T. Realmuto and Aaron Nola. Realmuto was still very good defensively last year, but I’d love to get just a bit more from his bat (he is a catcher, so he doesn’t have to be incredible). Nola has five years left on his deal, and I’d at least like a couple of them to look like his top ten Cy Young finishes. If those two are even just better than last year, the Phillies could be really outstanding.
The Phillies chose to bet a lot on their young guys for this season, and I have always liked that idea. If Crawford and Painter are what we have been lead to hope, and Otto Kemp does well with increased playing time, I can be very excited about this team. I think a lot of fans and Philadelphia-based media are looking for a reason to be worried about this team, knit-picking about the team not going after aging, frankly only modest impact free agents that probably wouldn’t have wildly changed the odds that this team is good. That’s silly and really won’t matter later. Look, I get that Adolis Garcia doesn’t excite some people, but it would be hard for him to actually be worse than Castellanos was in reality last year. You don’t love Alec Bohm? Fine, but don’t act like he’s a plague on the lineup, or whether he hits fourth or sixth is the difference between them winning 96 again or winning 77. These are small matters. The core of the team is the core. How they perform is basically everything.
I’m bullish. Very, very bullish.


It was kind of a tough week for a lot of Phillies fans, even if some of us are less mad than others. First, Ranger Suarez left for Boston. That was sort of a known for a while (at least that he’s probably leaving), but is still easily the biggest blow to the Phillies roster this offseason. Ranger broke out as a closer in 2021, and then as the #3 starter on the 2022 NL Champions. He famously got the last out of the 2022 NLCS (See above) and threw a shut out in game three of the World Series that year. He made the All-Star game in 2024. More than anything, he was dependable. You were going to get almost exactly 25 or 26 starts a season, his ERA would be in the threes, and he’d be money in the playoffs (other than 2023’s game seven). The Phillies should be able to recover from this loss between the returning Zack Wheeler and the arriving Andrew Painter, but shoulds aren’t assured. This one definitely hurts them and removes a fan favorite.
Now that we have gone through that, let’s get to what transpired this week and really has people up in arms. The Dodgers paid a literally absurd $60 million a year to Kyle Tucker, a very good player, but not nearly on the level of Judge, Ohtani, or Soto, even at his best. Hell, it’s a literal absurdity that this guy is going to make double Bryce Harper this season (actually more), but the Dodgers can do that, and they do. They have a gigantic market, the second largest city in America and the largest county by a lot, and their TV deal is a monstrosity. It also really doesn’t hurt that back in the 2011-2012 era when the McCourt family owned the team and was in bankruptcy, MLB created a sweetheart agreement with them that shielded most of their TV revenue from the revenue sharing agreement that governs other big markets, like their neighboring Angels, the New York teams, Philly, Chicago, Boston, and the San Francisco Giants. The deal made total sense at the time and was the right thing to do (MLB was never going to let the Dodgers go under). To the credit of the Dodgers ownership, they put the extra money they make directly back into signing players, which is what fans should want. With all of that said, that agreement is no long necessary to the survival of the Dodgers. It is long past time for MLB to wrap the sweetheart agreement up, or let the other big markets play under the same sweetheart deal for the duration of the Dodgers deal. The Dodgers aren’t cheating or even doing anything they shouldn’t, but it’s not a fair or equal system for even the other big spenders.
I mostly mention the Dodgers here because their Tucker deal set off dominoes that did in fact impact the Phillies. Man-child Mets owner Steve Cohen was so shocked that the best player on the market didn’t want his money (like Alonso and Diaz, which is telling), that he not only pivoted to his next target, he made him an offer that was 150% of his existing best offer, annually, up to that point. It looked like Bo Bichette was coming to Philadelphia as late as Friday morning, and had a seven year, $200 million ($28 million a year) offer in hand, but Cohen turned around and gave a player that really doesn’t even fit on his roster three years and $126 million ($42 million a year). While it’s true they had talked to Bichette before that, the offer came in after being rejected by Tucker, and appears to have been negotiating against himself- no one else even considered offering Bichette $42 million a year. Now, I’m not going to tell you Bichette isn’t good, or that I didn’t want him in Philly, that’s childish, however I’m going to tell you that I would have rioted if the Phillies paid him anything near that. Bichette was smart to accept the wild overpay from the Mets, even if it means he probably won’t win a championship for a bit. If he plays out the whole contract, he would be 30 years old and only need a $74 million deal to match the total of what the Phillies offered him. He’s now going to crush $200 million in free agency earnings and be set up for life. Good for him, I don’t blame him at all.
None of this was good for baseball. The Dodgers showed us in 2025 that they could literally limit each of their pitchers innings and sleep walk to 90 plus wins and a spot in the postseason, and signing Tucker and Diaz this offseason only reinforces that. By doing what they did, the Dodgers and Mets are only increasing the likelihood of a lockout after the 2026 season, giving the small market owners more leverage to call for salary caps or increased revenue sharing, things I absolutely hate because they reward shitty owners (looking at you Pirates and Athletics). Salary caps don’t work. The NHL’s salary cap wrecked the sport. Even basic trades are nearly impossible in the NBA because of the salary cap. People celebrate the NFL salary cap for “creating parity,” but tell that to continuously shitty franchises in Cleveland, Cincinnati, Dallas, and Las Vegas that turnout huge profits each year. The NFL salary cap has just watered down what a great team is. Now we’re probably going to have a lockout because owners won’t even be able to agree to what they want, and even if they do, the players will never go for that. Sure, Dodgers fans can say “cry harder” about it, but what’s the point of having a dynasty if the sport ends up skipping a year or two because of it?
If I ran MLB, I would make a few simple fixes that would even out a lot of these problems without a hard cap or lockout.
These are just a few ideas to try and bring competitive balance to the league. Look, we all know some NBA teams just make paper transactions to meet the salary minimum, and some of these owners will try to do that. We also know there are teams like Washington with huge markets and rich owners who aren’t even faking that they want to win right now, who would just do the bare minimum until they think they can win. At least under this system you would be preventing them from pocketing as much cash.
Now, so back to my Phillies. They did re-sign J.T. Realmuto this week for three years and $45 million. Technically when that becomes official they will have 41 players on the 40 man roster (and Justin Crawford will still need a spot), so someone will have to come off soon. This puts the current projected payroll at $316,780,437 for 2026. My guess is they will try to shop Garrett Stubbs or Rafael Marchan, as both catchers are out of options and one will have to clear waivers when they don’t make the team. Nick Castellanos is obviously a candidate to go now too, and with a lack of right handed hitting outfield and DH options left, he should have some market if the Phillies are willing to eat at least $15 million to move him. With that said, if we are not considering the clubhouse issues, Castellanos wouldn’t be the worst right-handed platoon partner with Brandon Marsh in left (Trust me, they aren’t considering it). Taijuan Walker and his $18,000,000 salary is a candidate to go, and the Phillies could probably move at least $8-10,000,000 of his money off the books now if they wanted. Given the loss of Ranger though, the rotation is a bit light and probably could use him around for depth. Of course, Alec Bohm, Bryson Stott, and Brandon Marsh are all potential trade pieces yet, particularly if the Phillies make any more free agency moves. The Phillies could use another depth pitcher, a right handed bat to hit behind Harper, and if we’re going with Marsh in left, perhaps an upgrade right-handed platoon partner.
The market is not dead yet either. Eugenio Suarez seems like the most straight forward offensive upgrade available. He’s right handed, he plays third base, and he hit 49 homers a year ago. He does strike out a lot, his defense isn’t good, and he’s old. If he can be had on a two year deal, I would be less than shocked if the Phillies paid him $25 million a year. Look, they were offering Bichette $28 million and Realmuto $12 million a year as of Friday morning, so Suarez for $25 million and Realmuto for $15 million fits exactly into the financial footprint. It also makes trading Bohm and his $10.2 million one year salary a pretty straight forward salary dump without a particular need in what you get back. Suarez is flawed in plenty of ways, and you can question if you want to sign him and put Aidan Miller at second if and when he arrives, but he’s a pretty straight forward move. He’d also be the best cleanup option the Phillies have had since Ryan Howard’s prime.
Of course there is also Cody Bellinger. The fit here is a little less obvious, as while Bellinger was probably only second to really Tucker on this market, he’s left handed and the Phillies have plenty of that. Of course, if they signed Bellinger, he’d probably replace left-handed hitting Brandon Marsh, so he doesn’t really make things worse. Bellinger can play any outfield spot, hits for power, and would probably mash in the Phillies ballpark. The Phillies could probably offer him the exact same seven year, $200 million deal they offered Bichette and get him too, as he is reportedly sticking to seven years in his talks with the Yankees. Do I love that deal with him? Look, I think he has a really good four years in front of him, I’d be fine with him at five, but those last two years will probably be ugly. Even so, the Phillies window is realistically three years with this group, so what if you eat a few bad years after that. Sure, he and Harper are both lefties, but both can hit lefties, so I don’t mind them hitting back to back. Now, it’s true that if you pay him $28-30 million, he and Realmuto are more expensive than they seemed to be willing to go before, but it would also open up Marsh for a trade that would even things back out. I get why some people don’t love this idea, but Bellinger is a great player and could be a decent fit for the Phillies if they want.
I also wouldn’t count out that they decide to just bring back Harrison Bader and role the dice with four starting outfielders on the opening day roster, playing whoever the hot hand is at any given time. In fact, I don’t really hate this at all. A two year or even three year deal around $12 million a year with Bader would free up some cash for the Phillies to even go out and look for another starting pitcher, perhaps an older guy that could give you 20 good starts or a swing man, and make trading Walker plausible again. I definitely wouldn’t be mad at that.
Somehow, despite all that happened, a lot more probably will happen in baseball over the next month. That’s what makes it fun though- scrolling twitter and reading all the rage tweets from people when the Dodgers land Peralta, or Phillies fans lamenting the team being “cheap” for not giving an infielder who has never hit 30 homers and has no position more money than Aaron Judge to play here this year. What would life be without this?

By my count, the Phillies payroll is around $302.7 million for 2026 currently, and that’s before you add on any luxury tax. They are just under a million from hitting the next tier of luxury tax, which is to say their next signing will literally cost them dollar for dollar whatever they spend. They also have a full 40 man roster currently and would have to drop someone to add anyone. Despite all of that, they almost certainly will make another move, regardless of who it is. Their roster is simply not quite as good as the Dodgers, and literally lacks a starting catcher.
The move that I and every other Phillies fan with a pulse wants is Bo Bichette. He’s right handed, he’s going to be an upgrade offensively at either of second or third base, he’s young, and yes, he’s actually good. Of course, it’s not necessarily going to be easy to get him- some of the other big spenders on the chart above also want him. He’s going to require years, and he’s going to require dollars. Probably eight to ten years for the Phillies to close the deal, and the dollars probably start around Trea Turner’s $27.273 million as a floor and move upward from there. If he’s an eight year deal at $30 million a year, at least in 2026 he’s actually costing $60 million unless the Phillies can shed enough salary to offset it.
That’s of course only one move. They need a catcher. They probably should be trying to bring back Ranger Suarez. Being conservative here, a late off-season spending spree on Bichette, Realmuto, and Suarez would probably cost $65-70 million. The Phillies could go for less expensive catching and pitching options and I wouldn’t be that mad, but you’re still talking about adding $40 million, which is actually $80 million. That’s a lot.
For this reason, there are some folks very skeptical that the Phillies can do any of this, let alone will. There’s some truth to their arguments, but I think the Phillies have already answered this, at least to a point. Back in December the Phillies offered J.T. Realmuto a contract that was reportedly somewhere near two years at $15 million a year. That money would have taken them over the next luxury tax threshold and cost them an actual $30 million this year. Assuming those numbers and reports are true, we know they were at least willing to go that far.
Let’s assume for a moment the Phillies would go a different direction than paying Realmuto and Suarez top market dollar. Let’s just start with a Bichette signing at $30 million and work from there (obviously I think the Phillies will try to buy that number down with years, but bare with me). One would assume that the Phillies will obviously try and move Nick Castellanos, but that’s likely only going to net a few million. Let’s guess $2 million for argument’s sake. They could put Taijuan Walker on the market, and I bet they would be able to get out of a portion of his contract, somewhere between $8 million and $10 million. If the Phillies moved those two and saved $10 million (for argument’s sake, again), now the Bichette signing is more like $40 million for this year, instead of $60 million post-tax, and the only issue is being a bit light on starting pitching until Zack Wheeler returns. It’s at least a start, and only about $10 million more expensive than the reported Realmuto deal would have been.
The obvious elephant in the room then is that the Phillies probably would be forced into a decision of who to keep between Alec Bohm, Bryson Stott, and Brandon Marsh. The general group thinking is Alec Bohm and his $10.2 million salary go- he makes the most, it’s a walk year, and the Phillies have kind of grown impatient with him. On the contrary though, he’s a right handed bat, you really are only trying to man third base until Aidan Miller is ready later this season or next, and he probably gets you the least back as a rental (the others have two years left). Obviously if you did move Bohm’s salary along with Castellanos and Walker, you’d basically cut the impact of the Bichette deal down to $10 million or less in taxable money, or less than you originally offered Realmuto. You could go bargain shopping then at catcher and getting a fifth starter, and probably come out right around what you originally planned to spend. That’s of course assuming you don’t fill one or two of these needs moving Bohm, Walker, and Castellanos.
There is an argument to deal at least one of Stott and Marsh though instead, and others have already made some of the arguments very well. It’s worth noting that under the assumption the Phillies get Bichette, Boston does not. Boston is actively seeking infield help up the middle and probably now at third base. Bryson Stott would probably have a ton of appeal to them, as they could move him back to shortstop and bump Trevor Story over to second, and have a really good defensive tandem up the middle. Boston could also want Bohm, or even Edmundo Sosa, and the Phillies could get out from under a lot of money if they somehow flipped any two of them. Boston is also a team that has a surplus of outfielders. The obvious name everyone will scream is Jarren Duran, but there will be a competitive market for him, and they have others too. What if the Phillies could pull off a move like that though? The market on Stott would be very healthy (Yankees? Angels?), and the Phillies could fill another big need by moving him. If they were to get a right-handed hitting starting corner outfielder, it would make Marsh available on the market then as well. Brandon Marsh is coming off of a very nice season and could very well land the Phillies back a catcher, a back end starting pitcher, or utility player as part of the package. Stott and Marsh together will make $11.1 million, or $900k more than Bohm, which would even further negate the impact of the Bichette signing on the luxury tax.
All of these are hypotheticals, and trades move slower than a lot of fans of baseball like. I’m not really sitting here saying that the answer is to trade Stott to Boston for an outfielder and turn around and trade Marsh for a starting catcher, while signing Bichette, trading Walker and Castellanos, and bringing in another arm. I’m mostly saying there are totally plausible ways though for the Phillies to afford Bichette and possibly even another player or two while staying somewhat within range of the budget they had set for themselves before. The presumption that signing Bichette is a $60 million cost this season sort of presumes they can do nothing between now and next off-season when they get hit with the bill. As I see it, the Phillies have multiple ways to re-tool their roster and stay somewhat close to budget. As for the details of those pathways, Dombrowski should be working on them now, so he can put his best offer forward to Bichette.

The Phillies reportedly met with Bo Bichette today. I don’t know if they planned to be in this position from the start or not, but here they are- Bichette is the clear best choice of all the offensive players on the market for the Phillies at this point. The only players who might be better, Tucker and Bellinger, are left handed. Bregman is gone. Eugenio Suarez is good, but considerably older. Okamoto and Murakami went elsewhere. Bichette might have always been the best option, given his age, what side of the plate he hits from, his potential positions, and how good of a player he is. Bichette is the guy the Phillies need right now.
The Phillies have not moved one dime of salary yet this off-season, and probably won’t until after Bichette is off the market and teams know what they need. Castellanos ($20 million), Walker ($18 million), Bohm ($10.2 million), Stott ($5.9 million), Marsh ($5.2 million), and Sosa ($4.4 million) are all still here, despite varying degrees of markets probably available. In fact, the Phillies payroll sits at a projected $302,705,437, including pre-arbitration contracts, deferment money from past contracts, player benefits, minor league payroll, bonus pool money, and all settled contracts. Bichette will have a very active market of big market teams interested in his services. Given that Bregman got $35 million a year for the next five years, it’s not unfair to think Bichette will get $30 million a year for the next ten, or damn close to it. Think of Trea Turner’s $27.273 million a year as a baseline here. The Phillies will also still need to do something about catcher and would really like to bring back Ranger Suarez. In other words, if Bichette is going to happen, expect a lot of creativity to happen fast.
Expect the Phillies to try to dump as much of Castellanos, Walker, and Bohm’s salary fast as they can. Of course, that is relative to them signing Bichette first. They are probably lining up the moving parts even as they figure out what they are able to offer to Bichette. Either this will be a quiet ending to an off-season that ultimately ends up largely with them running it back, or it will be a franchise altering roster shakeup that will resonate for years to come.
No big deal though.
*********************************************************************
Chase Utley is apparently gaining steam in Hall-of-Fame voting. Look, I’ll believe it when I see it. Each year he has wildly over performed his actual vote share among voters who release their ballot publicly when they vote. Those voters tend to be younger and tend to be more driven by advanced metrics, the two characteristics that coincide closest with voting for Utley. As of the last I read, he needs about 71% of all the remaining ballots to be for him to get in this year. I do not think he will.
Utley is a polarizing Hall of Fame candidate for a lot of reasons, but I do expect him to get in someday. I’m not sure he should, and I would vote for Jimmy Rollins first (I find analytics great for predicting future performance and awful for judging the final product at the end of their career), but the group think around baseball’s Hall voting is changing. Career milestone numbers and awards are being largely cast aside in favor of more in depth analytics and consideration of a player’s peak years in the league. Of course this new bias is largely driven by voters who view WAR (wins above replacement) as one of the better ways to judge a player, so guys with an even better peak five seasons (Ryan Howard), who played at a position with more elite offensive players (first base, outfield), and had less defensive value than middle infielders aren’t getting as much benefit here. I’d definitely have been a “no” on Utley two or three years ago, his peak just wasn’t enough for me. My mind is opening to this new way of thinking though, provided we take a longer look at a lot of other players who got passed by on the ballot.
Utley getting in will end up being really good for his 2008 teammates in the end. If Utley’s five year peak is enough to put him into the Hall, Ryan Howard’s also will now have a lot better chance than a lot of us would have thought when his career ended. Jimmy Rollins case is more based on his career milestone numbers (all time hits leader for his team, over 2,000) and his hardware (the MVP, gold gloves, All-Star Games, and ring), but I am not sure future veterans committees would pass over Jimmy if Chase is in. And if we’re putting in both, I’m suddenly a lot more alright with either one of them individually.