Well it’s time for our monthly QB rankings in the NFL. It’s going to take more than one month to change most of my top five, but Joe Burrow falls a bit for being hurt. I’m sorry, it’s just another injury and another slow start. He might be #1 on the field for 18 weeks. He has to do that though. There are starters moving up from playing well (Danny Dimes) and others moving down due to injuries and regression. There are others who just haven’t taken a leap yet, and we’ll see where they are in a month.
The tough thing early in the season with trying to rank the NFL’s teams in order is how much to weigh your gut takes on each team against their records. Do I think that there are 2-1 teams better than 3-0 teams, or even 1-2 teams better than 3-0 teams? Yeah, I do. Do I think beating the Giants 22-9 is a sign your team might not be good? Yes. Sorry, but some things just have to be quantified by your gut instinct. On the other hand, your record is who you are. Sure, there are still some frauds going into week four, but a few weeks down the road, those things will take care of themselves. For now, record is the #1 criteria. Then it’s opinion. Unfortunately, sometimes it’s personnel decisions that dictate order, like the Giants putting Jaxson Dart in to start the rest of the season. That feels to me like a team who is done already for the year.
This week’s winner- Dolphins Head Coach (for now) Mike McDaniel, with some incredible wisdom here. He’s so insightful and cutting edge. What do the analytics say?
Tom Brady was everything Peyton Manning was supposed to be. From the moment Manning arrived in Knoxville, Tennessee, the football world was grooming him for the throne. Manning had a problem though. New England had a coach/QB combo that played football right. They controlled the line of scrimmage, didn’t turn the ball over, made clutch plays, and played defense. Brady’s early career stats weren’t in Manning’s stratosphere, yet the part time starter at Michigan kept winning. He ended the St. Louis Rams run of greatness. He beat Andy Reid’s Eagles. Most importantly he beat Peyton Manning. He beat him over and over. And the media, and many fans, hated it. It was boring.
The NFL literally changed the rules about how much a defense could rough up receivers then. Manning got his Super Bowl. He’d get one more “excuse me” title later. Brady figured out the changes and simply became the greatest ever.
Patrick Mahomes doesn’t quite fit either archetype. People thought he had talent coming out of college. Then he far exceeded it. Almost immediately upon showing his abilities though, members of the NFL noise machine decided they wanted to declare him “possibly the greatest ever.” He put up big time stats. He won. The only stubborn detail in their way? A loss to Brady himself in an AFC Championship game, at home, and a blowout loss to Brady in the Super Bowl. Plenty of reporters tried to glaze over all of that though. Mahomes “wowed” them.
Until the Eagles came around.
Let’s be honest, the Eagles basically have beat the breaks off of Mahomes and his Chiefs. Sunday’s loss at home was a two score beating without a totally fictional roughing the passer to help him score late and make it look good. It was the second time in three years the Birds had to go to Arrowhead Stadium, and it was the second time in three years they won kind of clearly. Those two wins sandwich around one of the worst beatings in recent Super Bowls, last season, in which the Birds simply bullied Patrick, Travis, and Andy. Future Hall-of-Famer Chris Jones was left mentally broken, arguing with Jalen Hurts about stats on Sunday- as Hurts kneeled out another victory.
Let’s just be honest, the Chiefs “dynasty” was always a momentary blip on the radar, a mistake, a fraud. Their Super Bowl 57 victory over the Eagles aided by a field that strangely was wet and slippery, hindering the Eagles pass rush, and a defensive holding flag at the end of the game that (while it was a hold) had been allowed all game. Of the four games between these Eagles and these Chiefs, it is the clear outlier, the only game in which Mahomes looked almost as good as Hurts. The whole thing was set up for Mahomes to get his walk off victory, and second ring. Let’s be honest, the NFL wanted to have Super Bowl 59 go the same way. Mahomes get his threepeat, Andy Reid enter the GOAT conversation, and Travis and Taylor gracing our television set on their way to becoming engaged. The Chiefs just weren’t good enough though. The truth is, without questionable officiating and Kyle Shanahan being terrified of the Super Bowl, this team would be lucky to have one. The Chiefs are a very good team that the media and the NFL created a narrative of greatness around. The Eagles have figured it out and are beating the breaks off of it.
… And the media hates it.
Jalen Hurts doesn’t throw for big yardage. In fact, he didn’t have 100 yards passing in a win over the Chiefs last week. His rushing numbers are good, but they aren’t the kind of free wheeling, scrambling yards we used to get from say, Michael Vick. The man simply limits turnovers to nearly zero. His team runs the ball at will. They eat up clock in ways no other team can. His team plays hellacious defense (especially when Jalen Carter doesn’t get ejected) and harasses quarterbacks. It is reminiscent of the early Brady/Belichick Patriots- they play football right. They win the line. They win the turnover battle. They win the time of possession battle. As someone who hated Chip Kelly from the day we hired him, it warms my heart to see a coach win who eschews all of the modern “innovator” nonsense and wins football games the old school, real man way. Even better that these guys are my team.
So yeah, the “tush push.” Let’s be clear, the play itself is legal- if you’re crying about false starts, that’s always been a penalty on every play, so call it then (but what many of you think is lining up offsides or a false start, simply is not.). This play has been legal for a while, not just since 2022. This play is a quarterback sneak, with a push from behind. It’s a play to get one yard. Those complaining about player safety are silly- the Eagles linemen run this play all the time and are remarkably healthy. Tom Brady whining about the Eagles starting at “first and nine” is rich, as every good offensive line plays a much shorter game (especially his Patriots). The truth is, the “tush push” is beautiful football. It is a bigger, stronger offense, particularly the line, imposing it’s will on the defense. The “tush push” is what football actually is supposed to be, not your favorite fantasy football QB. Good football is played by teams that win on the line of scrimmage. Real football fans should love this play. What we are seeing is how far our discourse has been run down by fantasy football and gambling. Many of you are claiming you’d rather not see a football team play the proper way. Let’s be honest though, 100% of the complaining about the “tush push,” right down to Adam Schefter crying that the Chiefs “lost in March” is really about the Eagles winning football games. Some people hate the Eagles. The national press and many fans hate football that isn’t predicated off of a vertical passing game. Honestly, if all of these weak, impotent fan bases don’t want to see the “tush push,” the solution is simple- don’t get in 3-and-1 or 4-and-1 situations. Notice, nobody else can run this play nearly as well as the Eagles. They built their teams wrong.
The Eagles won two Super Bowls in the last eight years, and played in three. They’ve been in two.of the last three. They won last year. I’m still not ready to call this particular group a dynasty (the dynasty is Howie Roseman), but I would probably predict more titles coming. You just can’t project that though, health is a huge factor in it, and eventually some actually good coach and GM will come along and develop a plan that beats them. Right now though, the Eagles have the best formula in football to do what football is all about- win. Jalen Hurts is playing the quarterback position perfectly. This team is built to win. People hate it. They are crying so much they’re actually crying for the Mahomes Chiefs, the team they all complained was being helped by the NFL Officials for the last two years. Listen to yourselves. It’s pathetic. Grow up. Man up. Your team is being pushed around because they’re weak. This Eagles team plays football the right way.
Two weeks are in the books. In week one, it is probably too early to rank them. I did it anyway. Even though teams had a win or a loss, so much of the rankings was still based on the last time we had seen them, or last year. This week made sure to let us know that some teams that we thought sucked really do. Teams that looked reasonably decent in week one, like the Cowboys and Jets, showed us against a second team that most of what we saw was fake. Other teams that we thought were good, well they’re good. No shock. So this week, all teams now fit into one of three buckets: 2-0, 1-1, and 0-2. There’s still some biases from last year reflected, but you can’t be considered elite at 0-2. Also, you have teams like Dallas that won, but still suffer for how they won.
Week one is complete. This is probably way too early to rank the teams, but I did anyway. I put them in originalNFL draft order to start, then adjusted based on wins and losses, who they played, and how it looked. With all of that in mind, here’s my rankings from #1-32 in the NFL after week one.
Philadelphia Eagles
Buffalo Bills
Los Angeles Rams
Washington Commanders
Los Angeles Chargers
Kansas City Chiefs
Green Bay Packers
Baltimore Ravens
Minnesota Vikings
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Denver Broncos
Houston Texans
Cincinnati Bengals
Pittsburgh Steelers
Detroit Lions
Indianapolis Colts
San Francisco 49’ers
Seattle Seahawks
Chicago Bears
Atlanta Falcons
New York Jets
Arizona Cardinals
Dallas Cowboys
Las Vegas Raiders
Jacksonville Jaguars
Cleveland Browns
New England Patriots
Tennessee Titans
New Orleans Saints
Carolina Panthers
Miami Dolphins
New York Giants
Was I too hard on some teams? Yes. My feeling was some losses showed us a lot about the team losing. Some wins really didn’t inspire me a ton yet either. I need to see more from teams like the Jags, Raiders, and Cardinals, and found myself less impressed with them, than say the Jets. Is that likely to change? Yes. There are 17 more weeks of regular season football. This will move a lot.
Well, it’s time. The 2025 NFL Season is here, and right about now the banner is going up in Philadelphia. Yesterday I did my pre-season prediction for every game of the season. If I ever put this into parlay form, I would not only not win money, I would be institutionalized. I decided to pick my Eagles to repeat, because I still think they have the best overall roster in football and they’re winners. Something in my gut says they lose in the NFC title game or something because they get stuck on the road, but screw it, hope springs eternal. It is a brutal schedule though.
I picked an Eagles-Bengals Super Bowl, won by the Eagles. I picked the Eagles (NFC East), Lions (NFC North), Buccaneers (NFC South), Rams (NFC West), Bills (AFC East), Ravens (AFC North), Texans (AFC South), and Chiefs (AFC West) to win their divisions. I’m calling C.J. Stroud my dark horse pick for MVP.
I absolutely don’t care who the Eagles beat in the Super Bowl, anyone is fine with me. If we don’t win, I could live with watching the Bills, Ravens, Lions, or Bengals winning one, but I don’t think they will. I do want an Eagles-Chiefs III Super Bowl, and this time I want a 56-0 shut out so that Mahomes, Andy, and Travis can get one more ass whooping from this group. They need to pay dearly for the stolen championship of 2022.
Back in training camp, I tried my first hand at ranking the Quarterbacks of the NFL. A lot has changed since. No one has a QB4 now. Almost no one has a QB3. Every team has named their starter now. There’s a lot more clarity. Now that we got through that, I figured it was time to try my hand again.
Ok, I’ve seen enough. Enough posts about how average to below average QB’s are better than Jalen Hurts. Enough posts from the cockroaches Giants fans about how Jaxson Dart looks great in practice. Enough posts about absolutely nothing. It’s time to weigh in with my pre-season NFL QB power rankings.